845.896.7779     1123 MAIN STREET, FISHKILL, NEW YORK 12524  
STARTERS
Tomato Café Soup Cup $5  Bowl $6
A hearty, rustic Tomato Soup, house specialty made fresh from our secret recipe

Top it off with crumbled Applewood Smoked Bacon $1
or add a touch of cream if you wish 75¢

Fried Mozzarella $7.50
Triangles of mozzarella breaded, fried and served
with our house-made pomodoro sauce

Classic Bruschetta $7.50
Toasted brick oven bread topped with the classic combination
of tomato, basil, red onion and balsamic vinaigrette

Bruschetta of the Day $9
Toasted brick oven bread topped with a mixture
of vegetables and/or fruits, and other fresh ingredients

Arancini $10
Classic Italian rice balls stuffed with
mozzarella served with our Cafe’ pomodoro

The Café’s “Almost Famous” Eggplant Cakes $10
Roasted eggplant, pine nuts and fine herbs - lightly breaded,
seared and served with a roasted red pepper remoulade

Café Wings $10.50
Our take on the classic favorite – tossed in our house-made
sauce served with carrots, celery and blue cheese dressing

SALADS
We have suggested dressings for our salads, but please overrule us and substitute your choice of: café house dressing, balsamic vinaigrette, non-fat yogurt honey mustardred wine vinaigrette, creamy vinaigrette, real ranch, blue cheese, 
add grilled chicken...$4 add cajun chicken...$4
  add grilled tuna steak...$7  add grilled flat iron steak...$8
  add grilled shrimp(4)...$8 

Café House Salad $7.50
A simple salad of mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumber,
red onion and carrots tossed in our café house dressing

Caesar Salad $8.50
Romaine tossed with house-made, traditional dressing, our croutons and parmesan 

Insalata Greca $8
A Mediterranean salad of cherry tomatoes, cucumber, green peppers, calamata olives and ricotta salata, tossed with olive oil and fresh lemon juice  served over mixed greens...$2

Arugula Pasta Salad $9
Arugula tossed with penne, cherry tomatoes, shaved parmesan, olive oil, lemon juice and cracked pepper 
substitue with whole wheat penne...$1

Mozzarella & Tomato Salad $11
Fresh mozzarella, market tomatoes, fresh basil, capers and
house-made croutons tossed with olive oil, salt and pepper

Spinachi $11
Spinach topped with sautéed mushrooms, hard-boiled egg and crumbled applewood smoked bacon topped with our creamy vinaigrette

Harvest Salad $11
Mixed greens topped with pecans, dried cranberries,
and goat cheese, finished with our balsamic vinaigrette

Grilled Eggplant Salad $11.50
Mixed greens topped with grilled eggplant tossed with pine nuts, house made croutons and cherry tomatoes simply dressed with olive oil and lemon juice, finished with crumbled ricotta salata

Café Tuna Salad $15.50
Salad Nicoise, a fancy name for a classic salad – mixed greens, 
calamata olives, roasted potatoes, green beans, tomato, capers and
 hard-cooked eggs topped with grilled tuna and our red wine vinaigrette

Café Steak Salad $15.50
Grilled flat iron steak, we suggest medium rare, sliced thin and served over mixed greens tossed with grilled sweet onions, roasted red peppers, and our red wine vinaigrette
add crumbly bleu cheese for $1

ENTREES
add dinner salad $3.75 or dinner caesar salad...$4.25

Chicken Paillard $20 (half portion for $11) 
Chicken breast marinated with fresh herbs, grilled and served with roasted potatoes and your choice of sautéed spinach or green beans

 Café Parm Dinner
Your choice of grilled chicken, breaded chicken, marinated grilled eggplant or breaded eggplant, topped with Cafe’ pomodoro sauce and mozzarella served with a side of linguini or ziti
Chicken...half $11.50 / full $21 Eggplant...half $10.50 / full $19

Chicken Marsala $21 (half portion for $11.50) 
Classic blend of pan-seared chicken and mushrooms in a
herbed marsala sauce. Served with a side of linguini or ziti

Chicken Piccata $22 (half portion for $12) 
Not quite your “Nonna’s” Piccata. We take the classic, pan-seared chicken breast with lemon, butter and capers, and we add calamata olives, tomatoes and artichoke hearts. Served over linguini.

Tuna Nicoise $23 (half portion for $12.50) 
A deconstruction of our salad: tuna steak, simply grilled, we suggest seared rare or medium rare, topped with butter and capers, served with roasted potatoes and green beans – you are welcome to substitute sautéed spinach if you prefer

Steak Frites $25 (half portion for $13.50) 
A classic - Grilled flat-iron steak served with a creamy horseradish sauce. Served with fries and sauteed spinach.

Crab Cakes $19 (half portion for $10.50)
House made crab cakes topped with our remoulade sauce. Served with rice and choice of veg (spinach, green beans, or grilled veggies)

PASTAS
Add dinner salad $3.75 or dinner caesar salad...$4.25
Subsitute whole wheat penne for any pasta...$1.00
Subsitute gluten free fettucine...$2.50
add grilled chicken...$4 add cajun chicken...$4 
  add grilled tuna steak...$7  add grilled flat iron steak...$8  
add grilled shrimp(4)...$8 

Linguini Pomodoro $15 (half portion for $8.50) 
Our simple, classic house made sauce: tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic, and olive oil – tossed with linguini and topped with parmesan 
(add meatballs or sausage...$3)

Pasta Primavera $19 (half portion for $10.50)
Linguini tossed with zucchini, yellow squash, red peppers, mushrooms and spinach with your choice of a white wine lemon butter sauce or a light red sauce

Penne ala Vodka $20 (half portion for $11)
A classic Tomato cream sauce “fortified” with a shot of vodka

Penne Pesto $20 (half portion for $11) 
Fresh penne tossed with cream and our house made traditional pesto, topped with diced tomato and shaved parmesan

Macaroni & Cheese $20 (half portion for $11) 
Mac & Cheese for grown ups - fresh penne baked with our special
blend of cheeses (add applewood smoked bacon...$1)

Pasta Scotti $21 (half portion for $11.50)
Fresh rigatoni tossed with sausage, cannellini beans, spinach, garlic and olive oil

Chicken Sandoval $22 (half portion for $12) 
A staff favorite - pan-seared chicken topped with roasted red
peppers and fresh mozzarella served over spinach and fresh rigatoni

Beef Stroganoff $25 (half portion for $13.50) 
Classic European comfort food - steak tips, sweet onions and
mushrooms in a creamy beefy gravy served over buttered fresh rigatoni
SANDWICHES
All sandwiches served with your choice of french fries, home fries or side salad Subsitute a side caesar salad for 75¢
Subsitute sweet potato fries for 75¢

Café Grilled Cheese $7.50
A simple classic, served on fresh baked Peasant bread, whole wheat or sourdough rye with your choice of cheese: American, Swiss, provolone, mozzarella, cheddar or gruyère 

Top it with grilled tomato 50¢ Canadian bacon $1.50
or applewood smoked bacon $2.00
w/Tomato Soup…….Cup $12 Bowl $13

Café BLT $9
Another classic favorite, served on toasted Peasant bread, whole wheat or sourdough rye with grilled tomato, romaine lettuce, applewood
smoked bacon and a side of mayo
“Club It” add grilled chicken or oven roasted turkey...$4
w/Tomato Soup…….Cup $13.50 Bowl $14.50

Café Burger $11
Premium 8oz Angus burger served on a brioche roll, served with lettuce, tomato, and red onion.  Add your choice of cheese: American, Swiss, provolone, mozzarella, cheddar, gruyère...$1
Add: applewood smoked bacon...$2
 sautéed mushrooms, grilled onions...75¢

Café Turkey Burger $10
A healthier version of our Cafe‘ burger - premium 8oz ground turkey 
served on a brioche roll served with lettuce, tomato and red onion

Grilled Vegetable Sandwich $9.50
Eggplant, tomato, zucchini and squash, grilled and served on a fresh hero. Add your choice of cheese: American, Swiss, provolone, mozzarella, cheddar, gruyère, fresh mozzarella, goat cheese, ricotta salata...$1

The Café Mozzarella Sandwich $10
Thick slices of fresh mozzarella topped with fresh tomato and arugula,  drizzled with vinaigrette, served on a freshly baked hero.
add prosciutto...$3 add grilled eggplant...$1

Café Parms  
Your choice of “protein” or vegetable topped with Café pomodoro sauce and mozzarella on a fresh baked hero and finished in the oven…
Chicken: your choice of marinated and 
grilled or breaded cutlet $11
Sausage: add peppers and/or onions if you’re feelin’ it $10.50
Meatball: house made from our special recipe
 of beef and pork $10.50
Eggplant: your choice of marinated & grilled 
or traditional breaded & fried $10

Chicken & Mushroom Wedge $11.50
Marinated, grilled chicken breast topped with gruyère cheese,
sautéed mushrooms and arugula served on a fresh baked hero

Fishkill Cheesesteak $11.50
Shaved rib-eye steak, grilled and topped with American cheese
(of course you can substitute any cheese you please), served on a hero
Add any one or all of the following:
grilled onions, peppers or sautéed mushrooms


PIZZA
Personal (10 in) Small (14 in) Large (16 in)
(gluten free personal available - add $1.50)

Traditional Pies Tomato Café sauce topped with the finest mozzarella
Personal $10.50 Small $13 Large $14.50

White Pie Mozzarella topped with blended ricotta
Personal $12 Small $14.50  Large $16

Classic Toppings: pepperoni. sausage, meatball, mushroom, green peppers, onions, red onions, black olives, fresh garlic, & tomatoes.
Each Topping: Personal $1 Small/Large $2 
 Half Topping: Small/Large $1

Specialty Toppings: grilled eggplant, breaded eggplant, red peppers, artichoke hearts, calamata olives, spinach, Canadian bacon, pineapple, yellow squash, & zucchini. 
Each Topping: Personal $1.50 Small/Large $3
 Half Topping: Small/Large $1.50 

Premium Toppings: applewood smoked bacon, grilled chicken, breaded chicken, buffalo chicken, roasted red peppers, & prosciutto
Each Topping: Personal $2 Small/Large $4
  Half Topping: Small/Large $2

TOMATO CAFE SPECIALTY PIES
Margherita Our pomodoro sauce topped with fresh mozzarella
Personal $12 Small $14.50 Large $16

Bruschetta Pizza Mozzarella topped off with our classic bruschetta-tomato, basil, red onion & balsamic vinaigrette
Personal $12 Small $14.50 Large $16

BBQ Chicken Traditional pie topped with chicken tossed in BBQ sauce and finished with cheddar cheese and thin sliced red onion
Personal $13.50 Small $19  Large $20.50

Chicken Parm Pizza Traditional pie topped with pomodoro sauce, diced chicken cutlet, finished off with more mozzarella
Personal $13 Small $18.50 Large $20

Pesto Pizza Mozzarella covering our house made pesto sauce and finished with diced tomato
Personal $12.50 Small $17.50  Large $19

Pizza Salsiccia Pomodoro sauce topped with sausage and grilled onions finished with crumbled ricotta salata
Personal $14 Small $18.50 Large $20

Pizza alla Prosciutto Mozzarella topped with a touch of pomodoro sauce and  prosciutto, finished with arugula
Personal $14 Small $20 Large $21.50

Garden Pizza Traditional pie topped with every traditional
vegetable topping
Personal $14.50 Small $20.50 Large $22

Grilled Vegetable Pizza Mozzarella topped with grilled eggplant, tomato, zucchini and squash finished with a touch of fresh garlic
Personal $15 Small $22 Large $23.50

Pizza con Carne Traditional pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, meatball and bacon
Personal $15 Small $22 Large $23.50

Insalata Pizza Mozzarella topped off with a salad of greens, tomato and red onion tossed in our vinaigrette. 
Personal $12.50 Small $16.50 Large $18

Hawaiian Pizza  Traditional pie topped with Canadian bacon and pineapple
Personal $13 Small $18 Large $19.50

Calamata Pizza  Mozzarella topped with calamata olives, artichoke
hearts, tomatoes and garlic
Personal $15 Small $22 Large $23.50

Chicken Marsala Pizza  Mozzarella topped with
mushrooms, chicken and our housemade marsala sauce
Personal $14 Small $21 Large $22.50

TOMATO CAFE CALZONES
Traditional calzones filled with mozzarella, ricotta and parmesan cheese, served with a side of pomodoro sauce $8

Build your own Calzone…
Classic Fillings: pepperoni, sausage, meatball, mushrooms, black olives, fresh garlic, onions, peppers, tomato, anchovies, red onion Each Filling: 50¢

Specialty Fillings: grilled eggplant, breaded eggplant, red peppers, artichoke hearts, calamata olives, spinach, Canadian bacon, pineapple, yellow squash, & zucchini.  Each Filling: 75¢

Premium Fillings: applewood smoked bacon, grilled chicken, breaded chicken, buffalo chicken, roasted red peppers, & prosciutto  Each Filling: $1
BACK TO TOP